Tuesday, January 2, 2007

Too many clicks, Yahoo. Too many clicks.

One of the most confusing things about the new Yahoo is the number of times that you have to click to get to the content you're looking for. For example, the tabbed section on the top of the home page is theoretically nice as you can easily browse headlines.














If I click the "most featured link" at the top of the box, I go to that story as expected. (In this case, clicking "Can your boss be trusted" and clicking ">>Learn more" go to the story."

But if I click the headline for one of the other four links, shouldn't I expect to go to THAT story? Let's say I want to read about the four-day diet plan to jumpstart the new year, so I click it. I don't go to that story. Instead, it just becomes the story at the top of the box.














The problem is, no useful additional information is displayed when it's pushed to the top of the box. "This four-day diet plan will help you jumpstart your health regimen in the new year" does not actually provide more information to help me evaluate whether I want to read the story than "Four-day diet plan to jumpstart the new year." To view the story, I have to click TWICE -- once to move it to the top of the box, and then at the top of the box to get to the actual story.

The first time this happened, I just thought the links were dead because I couldn't believe I had to click that many times to get to the content and I didn't notice that the stuff at the top of the box changed because the text where my cursor was located did not.

Really, they should want me to go straight to the content! That's where the ads are!

It's a lot of unnecessary clicks over the course of the day.

Thursday, December 14, 2006

Beta means...um...beta. Except at Yahoo.

Now, I haven't worked around software development for a long time now, so maybe I'm wrong here, but doesn't beta mean pre-launch? Like, not fully tested, not ready to go live and replace whatever there used to be? Because at Yahoo, "beta" seems to mean "Without warning, we took away the site that you really like and that worked well and replaced it with a piece of dysfunctional garbage. But we know the new site doesn't work, so we're calling it 'beta."

This occurred twice in the past few weeks:

*Yahooligans, the kids' site which included a low-graphics, easy-to-use, quick-loading directory of vetted childrens' sites, went away without warning and was replaced with the "Yahoo Kids Beta." All the teachers at my kids' school are up in arms about it. The new site is all graphic, doesn't load quickly on older computers (deployed in many schools), and has replaced all front-page content with games and advertising. Now, the older site also had games and advertising, but it had SOME arguably educational links on the top page. More on the ways that the new Yahoo Kids site ignores the needs of teachers and parents and confuses young children in another post. The point here is that the old site went away without warning and was replaced with a slow clunky site that's labeled as a beta. If it's really a beta, why can't I get to the older site?

* Yahoo TV has been replaced by the "new" Yahoo TV Beta. There's a lot more content floating all over the main page. I'm sure there's a case to be made for it, and that the case is probably related to advertising revenue. So fine, whatever. I just want my TV listings. Unfortunately, they're not there. I've got the right service provider selected and all my favorites selected correctly, but the listings pages will not show more than the first few channels no matter whether I choose "all channels" or "favorite channels." The page is really long, like it's making space for the correctly sized grid, but...no grid. Images later.

The really irksome thing about the "betas?" There's no way to report a problem. If these were real betas, then the point would be for users to willingly test them and report issues. Instead, it's like we've been given completely buggy prelaunch software and been told to live with it. Well, I live with the Yahoo TV Beta problem by going on over to TV Guide. But the Yahoo Kids Beta is a bigger problem since there aren't a bunch of competitors that have engaging kid-safe content and a directory of thousands of kids' sites. I'd pay to host my OWN outdated version of the older Yahooligans directory just to have easy browsing access through the vetted information.

For Yahoo Maps and Yahoo Mail, something called a "Beta" has been available as an OPTION for several months. Presumably this is to work the kinks out and give people fair warning that the features they love are on the road to replacement. And the revamped main page was available as a "beta" for quite a while before everyone was required to switch over. Again, FAIR WARNING. But for TV and Kids, the change was thrust upon us without warning, without choice, and without recourse.